Best Innerspring Mattresses
There are good ways to get that well-deserved quality sleep, and your bed has a major thing to say about that, specifically the innerspring mattresses that have been around for over a 100 year already. Innerspring remains on the top spot for the most popular mattress type, but this doesn’t necessarily mean they have high customer approval and satisfaction rating, nevertheless. The most important things that we look for in an innerspring mattress (and you should too) include mattress density, the type, the number of coils used, motion transfer, and temperature sensitivity.
Top 10 Rated Innerspring Mattresses of 2020
What exactly is an innerspring mattress? This mattress type is commonly known as spring mattress, and it is mainly made up of coils for its internal construction and has 3 other components namely the support base layer, the comfort layer, and the fabric cover for the first cushion.
When it comes to a comfortable sleep on a budget, nothing beats the best innerspring mattresses. Mind you, while these bed types have been the most popular since the 1930s, it took the common man nearly 6 decades after their invention in 1871 to accept the design.
Consequently, their inventor- a German, Heinrich Westphal- died quite a poor chap having not earned much recognition or profit from his invention.
These beds have evolved significantly over the years, with the best models garnering a lot of praises for their incredible comfort levels and temperature management.
Today, most of the best innerspring mattresses in the market employ a system of individually pocketed coils. This design works like a charm in minimizing motion transfer – the major problem that has plagued these mattresses for decades. They are also the market leaders in terms of edge support – an area that latex and memory foam mattresses perform poorly.
So, what is the best coil mattress today?
It would take you a couple of weeks or even months to compare all the innerspring beds that the market offers. That’s why we decided to identify 11 best innerspring mattresses in 2020 to spring you to a mattress that meets your sleep needs without a lot of struggles.
11 Best Innerspring Mattresses Reviews
Beautyrest Silver Luxury Firm 600 Innerspring Mattress
Best firm innerspring mattress: Beautyrest is the flagship brand of the Simmons Bedding Company, based in Atlanta, Georgia. This manufacturer has been in the sleep business for over 100 years now- and while it’s particularly popular for its hotel-grade mattresses that cost up to 5 grand, its Silver line of mattresses is a great place to search for a slightly cheaper innerspring mattress for use at home.
The Silver Luxury Firm 600 that we are reviewing here might be a great choice if you are looking for a firm mattress, but also value some amount of softness.
Just so you know how firm it is, the Silver Luxury Firm 600 falls at 7 on our 1-10 firmness scale where 1 is softest and 10 is firmest.
Although it’s more on the firmer side, this 12’’ mattress has 4 layers of foam on top of the individually-pocketed coil system that gives it an incredible level of softness. This means that you get the continuous support that these mattresses are known for, without it being so stiff on your knees and hips.
A good thing about the foam layers is that they are all Certipur-US certified. Interestingly, these foams are designed to enhance airflow through the mattress. So, whether you live in Las Vegas or Hawaii, heating during the night won’t be an issue anymore.
- Excellent back support
- Great temperature management
- Superb edge support
- Does not require flipping
- It’s heavy to move around
Classic Brands Innerspring Pillow Top Mattress
Best innerspring mattress with pillow top: Classic Brands has always been a haven for homeowners looking for affordable beds- and this Pillow-Top Innerspring mattress is one of them.
This is a 10-inch mattress featuring a 6-inch system of individually coiled springs and a pillow top. Pillow top mattresses aren’t the most durable especially with daily use. With that in mind, we would only recommend this model if you want it for temporal or light use.
That’s to say that it might interest you if you want a mattress for a dorm or guest room. Considering its price tag, it might also be your go-to mattress if you want a cheap, firm mattress as you save for a high-end model.
The Classic Brands 10-inch Innerspring Mattress is a medium-firm mattress and falls at 6 on our firmness level scale. Thanks to the pillow top design, this mattress is notably soft and comfortable for both light and heavy sleepers.
- Affordable
- Pillow top design makes it comfortable
- Easy movements across the bed
- Mixed information regarding warranty
- Not the most durable
Signature Sleep 13-inch Hybrid Mattress
Best innerspring mattress for hot sleepers: Our next recommendation here is pretty much similar to the Classic Brands above as far as pillow-top design and pricing are concerned.
The Signature Sleep, however, is much more comfortable and we also expect it to last longer than the Classic Brands. So, if you want an affordable innerspring mattress for your master bedroom, this 13-inch hybrid mattress might fit the bill.
While this mattress is sold a soft bed, it is actually medium-firm and sits at 5 on our 1-10 softest-firmest scale. Worth mentioning, however, you might find it quite soft if you are above-average in terms of weight.
Its plush top is made up of a thin memory foam slab that allows you to melt into the mattress. This low-density foam coupled with the supportive base makes the Signature Sleep a great choice for side sleepers and anyone else who like the feeling of sleeping in a cloud.
No, this mattress does not retain heat credit to the low-density memory foam, coil technology, and bamboo cover. This decent heat control coupled with the 15 gauge coils used around the edges (the middle uses 13.5 gauge coils) makes the Signature Sleep one of the best innerspring mattresses for sex too.
- Sleeps cool (really cool)
- Top-in-class edge support
- Very comfortable
- Seemingly durable
- 1-year warranty is a joke
- Cover is not removable
Signature Sleep 6147459 Contour Hybrid 12″
Best innerspring mattress for back pain: The Signature Sleep Contour plays on the strengths of 2 mattress technologies to make it a favorite among people with back pain issues.
This is a 12-inch hybrid mattress employing a layer of memory foam in pillow-top style and a base of fully-encased 15-gauge coils.
Bringing these 2 technologies together makes the Contour a recommendable choice for people who love the pressure-relieving attributes of memory foam, but hate the sinking feeling that it creates.
The continuous support of the spring system beneath aims at maintaining your hips, shoulders, and spine in a natural alignment. This coupled with the body-molding comfort of the pillow-top is what will make you want to consider this mattress if you have a sore back.
Similar to other mattresses here, the Signature Sleep 6147459 Contour Hybrid 12″ mattresses has each of its springs encased in a thickly-padded cell. This not only prolongs its durability, but it also minimizes squeaks besides boosting the plush pillow-top’s motion isolation capability.
- Great value for money
- Soft yet very supportive
- Great pain and pressure relief
- Above-average motion isolation
- Has a mild chemical smell
Olee Sleep 13SM01Q Q13Sm01Molvc Mattress
Best innerspring mattress for multiple sleeping positions: Innerspring mattresses generally have lower price-points compared to their memory foam and latex mattress alternatives. But this does not always mean low-quality construction as the Olee Sleep 13SM01Q proves.
This is yet another very affordable alternative if you want an innerspring mattress that offers the versatility of gel-infused memory foam. The Olee Sleep is a 13-inch hybrid mattress with several layers of foam atop an innerspring base.
As it’s usually the case with innerspring mattresses, this bed has a medium-firm feel. The gel-infused memory foam layer on top, however, gives it an impressively soft and plush feel that lets you sink into the mattress while enjoying the constant support of the innerspring base.
There’s no doubt that most stomach, back, and side sleepers will appreciate the comfort level that this affordable innerspring mattress offers.
Thanks to the contouring ability of the memory foam comfort layer, you won’t be wrong to consider this mattress if you are dealing with back and joint pains as well.
You might experience a pungent chemical smell right out of the box. But most buyers report that it is not nerve-racking and disappears within a few hours or days utmost.
Sealy Response Premium 16-Inch Plush Euro Pillow Top Mattress
Best innerspring mattress for heavy people: The Sealy Response is for people who love their beds really firm. So, if you prefer sleeping on an ultra-soft bed, kindly consider other options on this list.
This is one of the firmest innerspring mattresses that we’ve come across so far. It might be a great choice for heavy stomach and back sleepers who demand proper full support for natural alignment of the body.
There are so many things to love about this mattress. But what attracted us to it most was its Posturepedic construction design. Generally, what this means is that the mattress is designed to offer targeted support where your body needs it most, that is, around the middle of the mattress.
While the manufacturer does not market it as a hybrid mattress, the Sealy Response has several layers of foam on top of the innerspring bedding that qualify it as one. These layers give the mattress a good amount of yield thereby resulting in a good level of comfort.
Although we wouldn’t recommend this mattress to people who sleep overly hot at night, the Sealy Response has a layer of Air Foam to promote airflow and a support gel foam that works by drawing heat away from you. It also has a soft knit fabric cover that boosts breathability.
LeesaSapira Luxury Hybrid Mattress
Best innerspring mattress for couples: Cloud-like softness and firm support rarely occur in the same sentence when reviewing the best innerspring mattresses. And that’s what gives the LeesaSapira mattress its competitive edge in this list.
This is a hybrid mattress that combines the pressure relieving properties of memory foam with the coveted support of a traditional bed. To be precise, our review team rated this mattress 6.6 on our firmness scale thereby putting it squarely between a soft and a firm bed.
The LeesaSapira is an 11-inch mattress featuring 5 layers of foam, and a spring base made of individually wrapped pocket coils.
This construction design offers you the best of these 2 worlds: it accommodates multiple sleeping positions, has excellent edge support, and unbeatable motion isolation for an innerspring mattress. Given all these functionalities, we’d not hesitate to recommend this mattress as the best innerspring mattress for couples.
Something else that we really like about this mattress is its 100-night trial period. In case you are not pleased with it, Leesa will send someone to pick it up for free (except for buyers in Hawaii and Alaska who may part with around $100). Yes, it’s that hassle-free. The chances are that you are going to keep it, though, and enjoy the 10-year warranty that it comes with.
Voila Luxury Hybrid Coil-Spring Latex Mattress
Best innerspring latex hybrid mattress: The Voila is, with zero doubts, the best definition for an innerspring hybrid mattress. While most mattresses of this type boast 5 layers of foam maximum, this mattress has 11 of them (you read that right).
But, of course, multiple layers don’t automatically correlate with a high level of comfort. So, who is this mattress for, and how does it feel to sleep on it?
The Voila Hybrid spring latex mattress is for people who like sleeping on a memory foam but hate sleeping ‘inside’ the mattress. Its medium-firm feel with a little give that makes it a good bet for heavy stomach and back sleepers (for lightweight side sleepers, consider the Linenspa 10-inch reviewed later in this article).
At the top, this mattress has 2 layers of gel-infused memory foam followed by a slab of Talalay latex. These layers are responsible for the medium-firm feel in this mattress. They also give it its pressure relief, contour, and comfort properties.
Speaking of contouring, the Talalay latex doubled with the 6 ¼-inch coil base means that you won’t be sinking uncomfortably into the gel memory foam comfort layers.
This mattress is an excellent performer in motion isolation too- a feature that you really want to check out for when buyingthe best innerspring mattress for couples.
Lastly, while it’s a no-match for the LeesaSapira in terms of edge support, you won’t roll off the Voila as you’d do on the Sealy Response that we saw earlier.
ZinusiCoil 10 Inch Support Plus Mattress (Extra Firm)
Best Innerspring Mattress for Heavy People: Any plus-size individual will affirm that getting the best mattress for heavy people isn’t an easy task.
Heavy individuals (over 230 pounds) exert a significant amount of pressure on a mattress and might sink uncomfortably if the mattress is thin and of low density.
As a general rule, heavier people should get a mattress that is at least 10 inches thick, and with a firm feel more so if they sleep on their stomach. The Zinus Support Plus is a highly recommendable model for this purpose if you are eyeing an innerspring bed.
This mattress comes in 2 thicknesses; 10 and 12 inches. The 10-inch mattress that we are reviewing here has a 1.5-inch comfort foam layer and a 1-inch high-density support layer atop a 7.5-inch coil system base.
The Zinus 10-inch has an extra firm feel plus an excellent support that makes it a reliable bed for heavier and obese stomach sleepers. The comfort layer has a fair amount of contouring that aids in relieving back pains and pressure points.
Linenspa 10’’ Memory Foam and Innerspring Hybrid Mattress
Best innerspring mattress for affordability: We are now switching gear to a seriously cheap mattress that has commanded tons of respect among homeowners on a budget.
The Linenspa is a hybrid mattress with a very simple construction design- but it still works as expected. This 10-inch mattress features a 0.5-inch polyester-blend cover that has been quilted with memory foam layer to welcome you with immediate pressure relief.
Right beneath the cover is a 1.5-inch gentle poly foam layer. This comfort layer complements the memory foam quilted cover by allowing some sinkage into the mattress. However, it has a good amount of responsiveness so you won’t experience that stuck-in-the-mattress feeling that memory foam beds are known for.
The support layer is a 6.5-inch system of spring coils that add a satisfying amount of bounce to the mix. It also promotes airflow so you won’t be drowning in your own sweat during sleep.
With regard to performance, the Linenspa hybrid mattress works well mostly with average-weight back sleepers and lightweight side sleepers. Heavier-than-average side sleepers require a slightly softer mattress and might experience some pressure around the shoulders and hips on this one.
Signature Sleep Contour 8-inch Mattress
Best innerspring mattress for side sleepers: Our last recommendation here is one of the best options for average-weight side sleepers.
This is an 8-inch mattress that might also be a great pick if you are hunting for a good innerspring mattress for kids. The fact that most people are side sleepers also qualifies it as a good pick for a guest room.
If we were to pick just one unique feature of the Signature Sleep Contour, that would be its flippable design that is made possible by a layer of memory foam on both sides.
This construction design allows you to flip the mattress every time you are changing the sheets (or at least twice per year) thereby leading to even wearing. It also prolongs the lifespan of the mattress so you get a mattress that lasts almost 2 times longer than a single-sided mattress.
The Signature Sleep Contour has a medium-firm feel and sits at 6 on our firmness scale. As I hinted earlier on, this softness makes it a good choice for side sleepers. We would, however, recommend it to average-weight people (200lbs and below) debit to its thickness.
Thanks to its 800-coil count, this mattress does a very good job in motion isolation. Another bonus feature of this mattress is that it does not retain heat. Put these 2 features together plus the fact that it is flippable and you get a very reliable innerspring mattress for couples too.
Wrapping the reviews
The benefits of an innerspring mattress are simply endless. These beds have the best temperature management- a very important feature for people who sleep hot at night. They also have limited conforming ability which means that unlike their memory foam competitors, movement across the bed and even changing positions is much easier. Perhaps one feature that trumps all others is their wide variety and sophistication today, thanks to modern technological advancement. Whether you are looking for a mattress that includes the contourability of memory foam, or the natural wholesomeness of latex, the world of the best innerspring mattresses in 2020 is bound to have a bed for everyone.
How to Choose the Best Innerspring Mattress?
Coil System and Foam Layers
Innerspring mattresses are not created equal, but they do have a common denominator when it comes to their basic construction and layering particularly with the coil system and their distinct foam layers that may vary according to the type of foams and fabrics used. The support base or coil system layer is the spring core made from steel springs or also known as coils or coil springs, and the number of coils would vary with different manufacturers. The comfort layer of the mattress is also referred to as the upholstery layer that is the topmost level, made up of numerous types of foams or fibers such as latex, gel memory foam, polyurethane foam, and visco-elastic, offering cushion at the surface for optimal comfort. The last layer is the fabric cover which encases the entire mattress and may come with different materials such as polyester yarn, wool, silk, rayon, and cotton.
Coil Types
Coil spring mattresses differ in the coil design and pattern that is utilized within the spring bed, all having different effects on the overall quality and firmness level of the unit.
- Open Coils: This type of spring mattress is more commonly known as the Bonnell and the oldest and most widespread coil spring system that is used for cheaper mattresses, consisting mainly of multiple tempered steel springs with hourglass shapes that are laced together, forming the main bulk or body of the bed structure.
- Continuous Coils: The structure of the rows of coil springs is molded into springs that run through the width and length of the bed, making the structure of the long tempered steel wire a good option for its conforming ability and motion isolation.
- Offset Coils: The more expensive innerspring mattress version compared to its Bonnell counterpart, offset coil beds have similar design and structure types, but the individual springs are hinged together to ensure better body contouring and motion transfer.
- Pocket Spring: The pocket spring or pocket coil mattress consists of hundreds or thousands of independently wrapped springs using different types of fabric or cloth, making it one of the best innerspring mattresses due to its superior support, longevity, and motion transfer.
Mattress Firmness
The firmness of the innerspring mattress is secured through factors such as the gauge of the coils, whereas the mattresses with a much lower gauge number have much thicker coils. For instance, mattresses with 12.5 gauge coils are significantly firmer compared to those with 15.5 gauge coils, and so on. The coil gauge also delivers different levels of bouncing effect on the mattress, whereas lower coil gauges are firmer and higher gauges have a softer or bouncier impact. In the previous 5 decades, the standard coil count for a queen-sized bed is 800 coils which offer enough support for two people who weigh not more than 800 lbs. You can determine the appropriate coil count for your mattress through comparing it with foam weights, qualities, and types.
Testing the mattress for firmness requires you to spend at least 10 minutes on different spring mattress types and determine the pros and cons of each unit.Of course feeling comfortable is the most important factor but it’s also crucial to have proper body alignment. Spinal alignment is a factor which simply can’t be neglected, even if not now, later it will cause back pain. Here is the illustrated version of how “Just right” mattress should be.
Heat-Trapping, Motion Transfer, Edge Support, Off-Gassing
The different coil types of the mattress typically have their corresponding features especially when it comes to heat trapping, edge support, and motion transfer. The degree of support, heat transfer and motion isolation depends on what type of construction the mattress has. Open coil mattresses have lesser to average motion isolation, support, heat retention, and durability compared to higher end models such as pocket spring mattress beds. But regardless of the coil type, spring mattresses absorb heat pretty well due to their metallic nature and sleeping cool factor is better than in hybrid and foam mattresses (especially memory foam).
Innerspring mattresses have above-average motion transfer compared to latex and memory foam mattresses that have high-density base layers. Providing more support and equal weight distribution, so that you would not disturb the person lying next to you when you toss and turn or get off the bed. The heat retention of innerspring depends on the comfort layer that is combined, as there are hybrid models that have latex, poly foam, or memory foam blends. The fabric cover of the innerspring also contributes to the coolness of the mattress.
Edge support for spring beds depends on the mattress’ coil construction since there are coil spring beds that can withstand an enormous amount of pressure and weight with minimal to unnoticeable sagging issues. Innerspring mattresses do have certain features that could compete with the durability of its latex and memory foam counterparts, especially pocket spring mattresses with the innovative technology that is used for individually wrapped coil springs, however, the result would still be relatively different, depending on the user’s weight and body frame.
| Memory Foam | Latex | Innersping |
|---|---|---|
Durability of Innerspring Mattresses
Innerspring mattresses, even premium models, and brands, generally do not last longer than much higher end types such as memory foam or latex mattresses, due to the higher sagging rate of the mattress that significantly affects its longevity or lifespan. The average lifespan of spring or coil mattress beds is only up to 6 years or less while the best memory foam mattresses could last longer without any sagging issues. Top latex mattresses, on the other hand, is one of the longest lasting mattress types in the industry, with minimal to no sagging problems that could last for decades, especially with the right care and maintenance.
back to menu ↑Pros and Cons of Spring Mattresses
Comfort Test
Testing how the spring mattress feels and its comfort level, in general, is thoroughly validated if you essential lie on the bed surface to feel how comfortable it is. Put pressure on the mattress through your hand or palm and see how it responds to the weight exerted on its surface. Some beds are firmer, and others are so hard that you can feel the springs, while others have a bouncing effect.
Choosing the best innerspring mattress would mainly depend on your preferred kind of sleep position such as the medium-firm to soft level is ideal for side sleepers or lighter individuals as much firmer spring beds have a hard effect when there is less pressure or weight on the surface. Stomach and back sleepers, as well as heavier individuals, require a much firmer spring bed to ensure back support and protection of pressure points as firmer springs are known to provide a satisfactory effect to counter back pain and physiological discomforts.
back to menu ↑Budget
Innerspring mattresses are quite popular due to their affordable and reasonable price. There are premium quality brands and models that have already been tested and proven for quality and performance. Some of the most affordable units with top quality features and designs include the Zinus innerspring collection, Signature Sleep, Serta, Sealy, and Saatva. Spring mattresses have cheap, mid-range and much costlier models depending on the design and manufacturing features of the bed. However, spending on coil spring beds makes a lot of sense especially with brands that are proven to last for years with minimal sagging and other pertinent issues.
| Twin | Full | Queen | King | Cal. King | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Median Price | $432 | $646 | $756 | $1224 | $1487 |
| Number Analyzed | 199 | 244 | 268 | 225 | 141 |
Warranty and Trial Days
Different manufacturers offer varied warranty protection and trial period for their products. Warranties usually range between 5 and 25 years at the maximum for premium quality and high-end mattress models and brands. Trial periods also depend on the manufacturer but the typical time frame is from 30 to 120 days. Buying your spring mattress bed online does not give you a chance to do a comfort test before you purchase the unit, but manufacturers do offer trial periods and observe return policies so that you can have a hassle-free investment on your innerspring bed.
back to menu ↑Conclusion
Spring or coil mattress beds are popular then and now and the continuous evolution and developments on this bed type are proof that the spring bed industry is not going anywhere soon. Spring beds have their share of pros and cons, but if you want a budget-friendly and affordable bed without sacrificing the quality, the innerspring selection is the best place to do your search. The best innerspring mattresses are usually the ones with pocket spring or custom patent designs, offering exceptional edge support, minimal motion transfer, and excellent body contouring abilities, however, there may be issues of noise over time, and those are not as durable as latex and memory foam beds are.
